5-Cup Coffee Makers: Our Top Picks (2024)

Why Choose a 5-Cup Coffee Maker?

In the world of coffee makers, products tend to cater to those who want large coffee pots that make enough brew for an entire family or those who just want a single cup. However, if you’re searching for something in between, a 5-cup coffee maker might be the perfect solution. 

These machines are often smaller than large pots, so they can save energy, counter space, and money. Keep reading to learn about some of the most popular options for 5-cup coffee makers.

Our Top Picks: 5-Cup Coffee Makers

Zojirushi Zutto Coffee Maker

4.4 out of 5

Pros:

• Long-lasting filter
• Modern design
• Space saver

Cons:

• Expensive
• Lacks advanced features

Zojirushi, a Japanese company known for its beverage dispensers and consumer electronics, sells one of the highest-rated coffee pots on the market. The Zutto coffee maker features a removable water tank and a charcoal water filter that lasts up to two years. It starts brewing with a single button, and it automatically keeps your brewed coffee warm. 

The sleek and modern design results in a narrow product, making the Zojirushi Zutto coffee maker a great space saver. Reviewers note that the coffee is exceptional but is more expensive than its competitors.

Black+Decker 5-Cup Maker

4.3 out of 5

Pros:

• Durable
• Dishwasher-safe parts
• Nonstick hot plate 

Cons:

• No automatic shut-off
• No permanent filter
• No anti-drip

Praised for its durability, the programmable Black+Decker has plenty of features that make it stand out. Unlike some 5-cup coffee pots, this one has a dishwasher-safe carafe and filter basket. The glass carafe, which is made out of reinforced Duralife, is made to last. Its nonstick hot plate keeps coffee warm for an hour after brewing.

However, it lacks anti-drip and automatic shut-off features. Additionally, the Black+Decker pot does not have a permanent filter, so users must buy a permanent filter or paper filter independently.

Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker

4.4 out of 5

Pros:

• Space saver
• Programmable brewing times
• Convenient

Cons:

• Reports of lukewarm coffee
• Might be noisy

Despite its compact size, the Capresso 5-cup mini drip coffee maker is a small but mighty machine with plenty of features. It’s programmable, so users can set it to brew automatically at their preferred time. You can put your coffee grounds in the reusable filter the night before and have the Capresso pot programmed to start brewing it the following day. It’s made from stainless steel and features a hot plate that keeps coffee warm for up to two hours.

Users say the Capresso coffee pot is long-lasting and convenient for small spaces. Reviewers have also noted the machine’s quick brewing time and its convenient drip stop, but some have reported that their coffee wasn’t made hot enough.

Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

4.3 out of 5

Pros:

• Advanced settings
• Permanent filter
• The choice between stainless steel and glass carafe

Cons:

• Expensive
• Some reports of drips 

Made by one of the most well-known coffee appliance brands, the Mr. Coffee advanced brew 5-cup coffee pot is a famous programmable coffee maker. Functions include delayed brewing, setting a brewing time, and even altering the brew strength, which makes the product particularly appealing to coffee lovers. 

It features a permanent filter, and you can choose between a glass or a stainless steel coffee carafe. The latter is made from heat-retaining material, ensuring that brewed coffee will stay warm.

One of the main drawbacks of the Mr. Coffee advanced brew coffee maker is that it’s on the more expensive side of the spectrum of similar products.

AmazonBasics 5-Cup

4.2 out of 5

Pros:

• Affordable
• Easy to use
• Easy cleanup

Cons:

• No advanced settings
• It brews less than other coffee pots
• Not dishwasher safe

If you’re looking for a convenient and affordable coffee pot, the AmazonBasics 5-cup coffee maker might be a fantastic option. The machine is relatively easy to use with a simple on/off switch. It also includes a stain-resistant hot plate, a feature that prevents overheating, and a reusable filter that can easily be cleaned. Users adore the product’s low price, compact size, easy cleanup, and usability. 

However, keep in mind that the simplicity of the AmazonBasics coffee maker means that it lacks more advanced features like programmable settings for brewing delays. Additionally, it can brew five 5oz cups, which are smaller than some consider enough for a cup.

Holstein Housewares 5-cup compact coffee maker

4.3 out of 5

Pros:

• Vibrant color options
• User-friendly
• It comes with a measuring spoon and filter

Cons:

• It Brews less than other coffee pots
• No advanced settings
• No auto-shut off

If you’re on the hunt for an excellent coffee maker that also has style, look no further than the Holstein Housewares 5-cup compact coffee maker. It's offered in various vibrant colors, from red to teal to mint to yellow, and the pot handle even matches the rest of the machine.

Not only does the Holstein Housewares coffee maker add a pop of color to your kitchen counter, but it’s also user-friendly. It includes a measuring spoon and a removable cone filter, so there’s no need to buy paper filters. To begin brewing, just press the on/off switch on the side of the machine.

The Holstein Housewares has drawbacks similar to those of the AmazonBasics machine. Reviewers have noted that it brews enough only for five 5oz cups of coffee and lacks programmable settings.